Sunday, May 30, 2010

Why I'm Leaving the Legion of Christ (Part 1)

An outsider looking in

The reasons behind my decision to leave the Legion of Christ are many. If there were just one reason I would be the first to admit to being rash. It has been a long time coming and many are the contributing factors. Of these factors the most enduring has been a sense being an outsider.
For years I felt as though I was part of the family, I knew everyone, I knew the way of life and practiced it to the best of my ability. But there was something wrong. Interiorly I wasn’t rejecting anything: I embraced it all and loved it.
So often I felt like an outsider looking in.
As time went by the feeling grew. I tried my best to identify the cause and deal with it. I sought help in confession and spiritual direction, and I believe the advice I was given was good: was my prayer life going well? Was I interiorly rejecting something? Was I toying with temptation? I sincerely examined myself and redoubled my efforts. But that thing was still there.
It is only recently that I have been able to give the thing a name: suspicion.
Suspicion, not in the paranoical sense of “their out to get me”. Suspicion in the sense some things I heard could not be true. I’ll give one example, but there are others. It was well known to us, and explained from the beginning that Fr Maciel would travel alone from time to time and take sums of money for his acts of charity. This first time I heard this I was suspicios. If someone you knows disappears for a week or two and no one knows where he has been, then comes back, business as usual, wouldn’t you be suspicious?
All my suspicions had their explanation, but for me were never resolved. I don’t claim to be a suspicios person. I don’s suspect everyone around me us up to no good. But if I see something wrong I point it out. And if I find out I was wrong, I admit it.
Turns out my suspicions weren’t wrong after all.


  1. Alas, I am a bit on the gullible side, and I never doubted those explanations, so it really hit me hard when I learned the truth. When the whole façade fell I had a tremendous feeling of betrayal.

  2. I admire your courage and conviction to full disclosure. However, it feels like we are not getting the full story. I have read part 1 and part and I understand that 1) You were lied to about Maciel's doings, and 2) Spiritual direction was not confidential as you had reasonably expected it to be. But it feels like there are 5 or 6 more parts to come - but we are not seeing them.

    Also, you discussed an open letter, but you don't share the open letter with us. If it's an open letter, why not post it here?

    I sense that in a moment of clarity or a moment of anger (it is not for me to say which) you determined that people needed to know certain truths about what you were going through. But it seems like shortly thereafter some remorse, guilt, or fear set in and you are being very selective about what to share.

    I can only say that as a member of RC, I am hanging on and praying that the full truth comes out so that a legitimate purification and redefinition can commence. For many of us, it has been and continues to be the lies and the spin that are just as damaging if not more to the Legion and RC than the actions of Maciel.


All comments are welcomed and posted immediately.
Be respectful. Offensive comments may be deleted.